Are You Wasting Your Money on Credit Monitoring?

By Bryant Sandburg, Identity Protection Specialist


Identity theft is the world's fastest growing "white collar" crime. It's now a $105 billion cash cow for professional criminals—bigger than illegal drug trafficking in the U.S.— with more than 20 million victims expected this year (2008). As a result, a huge new industry has bloomed: the identity protection business.

One of the most heavily advertised items on radio and TV these days is credit monitoring. Companies like LifeLock, TrustedID, FreeCreditReport.com, and others warn of the dangers of identity theft and then push the idea that all you have to do is have them watch your credit, put a freeze or fraud alert on it, and you'll be OK.

Here's the problem with that. Only one-third of all identity theft cases have anything to do with credit fraud. Which means that the majority of these crimes—two thirds— are committed in ways that are not covered by any of those heavily advertised programs.

How do you find out if an illegal alien has a driver's license with your name on it? How do you find out that someone got a job using your social security number? Or a passport? None of those things will ever show up on a credit report.

And that thing about putting a fraud alert on your credit? Turns out that's not such a good idea, either. In the first place, a fraud alert on your credit record can cause you inconvenience and embarrassment. What if you are shopping in a store that has a great today-only offer if you just open a charge account? They check your credit, right? Well, only about 50% of the time. Did you know that? If they do the credit check, you get an instant denial, and maybe some funny looks from a store clerk. If they don't check it, well, you're OK. But so would a thief 50% of the time!

Let's take a closer look at that 67% of non-credit-related identity theft crimes. How do thieves really get their hands on your information? According to the experts at the Federal Trade Commission, the FBI, and independent sources such as the Identity Theft Resource Center, there are three main sources.

3 Sources of Identity Information

#1. Public records
Your information is scattered in records all over the place, collected by every agency under the sun since the day you were born. Often these records are open to public view. Property records, for example, are public, and if you've ever had a mortgage there's a good chance your social security number is right there for anyone to see.  

#2. Data breaches
The personal information of more than half the U.S. population has been exposed due to data breaches. From January 2005 to the end of June 2008, over 230 million records have been lost or stolen from companies and agencies nationwide. In 2007 alone, the Identity Theft Resource Center identified 446 data breaches with more than 127 million records exposed. Much of this data reaches criminal hands on the black market.

#3. Mail theft, dumpster diving, and other
Rings of thieves break into mail boxes looking for mail that may have your information. Bank statements, for example.

The fact that your personal information records may have been exposed doesn't mean your identity has already been stolen. But it could be "out there" circulating in the underground "id" markets where no credit monitor will ever find it.

The reality is that credit monitoring is not identity protection.


Are You Wasting Your Money on Credit Monitoring? By Bryant Sandburg
Page 1/3 | Prev | Next